Choosing to Err on the Side of Grace  

Posted by Adam in , , , ,

Within the last couple of decades, many in our fellowship began to rediscover the concept of grace. In my opinion, this was a fascinating and much needed conversation that didn't go far enough. Many of us moved from a version of Christianity that often devolved into an earned and maintained salvation, to a version of Christianity that received salvation as a gift...that can often devolve into a subculture of entitlement, who's mantra is "I don't have to!" It never occurred to us that the question we were seeking to answer, might actually be a poorly framed question, suggesting a limited selection of anemic answers. We didn't notice that we were simply selecting the other side of an inadequate coin. We focussed on what grace freed us from, but stopped short of exploring what grace freed us "to".

Biblically, grace seems to be a proactive, transformative reality. It is a gift, but it is a gift that, once received, must be reflected and modeled to the rest of the world. As Scot McKnight suggests in his book, Embracing Grace: A Gospel for All of Us, once we embrace grace, we are to become an "embracing" people who exhibit grace toward the other...precisely because it is unmerited. It is less a benefit for members of a club...and more a new reality that they have bought into. To accept it for myself and refuse to extend it to others betrays both the gift of grace and the Giver. Don't just take my word for it, Jesus actually has quite a bit to say about this in the gospels (i.e. his comments on forgiveness after "The Lord's Prayer" and the Parable of the Unforgiving Servant...just for starters)

It's usually at this point that the fear impulse kicks in. What if we're wrong? This is the fear that haunts those raised in our tradition. Let me clear it up for you. We are. We have 3 pound brains and we dare to speak of an infinite God. When asked if he would fellowship a "brother in error", Fred McClure used to routinely respond "I don't have any other kind. We're all in error on something." N.T. Wright regularly begins his lectures by saying something to the effect of "I'm wrong about roughly 1/3 of what I'm telling you. I just have no idea which 1/3 that is." And thank God for His grace that washes over sin and "error" as he is actively working to form me into the image of His son...into the future where His dream for me and the world are reality.

The Bible is quite clear that the measure of judgment we apply to others will be applied to us. While I highly doubt that the Bible's concept of judgment is as equivalent to the American judicial system as we tend to presuppose in these discussions, the implications are hard to miss. We are going to be wrong about some things, but if, when it comes to judgment, "the measure I use" will be "measured to me", I want to "err" on the side of grace.

This entry was posted on Thursday, March 19, 2009 at Thursday, March 19, 2009 and is filed under , , , , . You can follow any responses to this entry through the comments feed .


solid post. that's right I said "solid" from like the 70's. what you said resonates with some things that I have been thinking about this week and the blog I posted yesterday would be a fitting comment to what you wrote...

March 19, 2009 at 1:19 PM

There is a fascinating statement by Paul that "grace teaches us to say no..." Until you learn to say no to a lot of other things you can never really say yes to anything. Leaving all our options open is really just a way of saying "I am lazy and unwilling to make a commitment to anything."

Living in the grace of Jesus is the most difficult thing I have ever attempted.

March 19, 2009 at 3:16 PM


Spot on, good man!

From my perspective, you're only wrong about 1/3 of the time and it's clearly the 1/3 you get from Tom Wright. ;-)

March 19, 2009 at 6:05 PM


Thanks for this post. I just found your coop blog and am looking forward to more.

Matt Dowling

March 26, 2009 at 9:57 AM

Post a Comment